Short answer: It depends on what you value. Windows' own Storage Sense and Disk Cleanup cost nothing and handle temporary files and update leftovers. BleachBit is a free, open-source cleaner. Freemium cleaners such as Rain Cleaner add a preview and an explanation for each item; Rain Cleaner Free has no ads. Compare preview, undo, ads, data handling and licensing on the official pages.
Why people look for an alternative
Common reasons are a preference for software without ads or bundled offers, a different licensing model, or wanting more control and more explanation about what will be removed. Windows itself also cleans a lot, so some people find they need nothing extra.
What to compare in a Windows cleaner
Preview before cleanup: can you see what will change before it happens? Undo or recovery: can a change be reversed? Ads and bundles: what does the installer offer? Data handling: what does the tool send, and is it explained? Open source or proprietary: these are different trust models, and either can be a reasonable choice. Windows versions: check that your edition and architecture are supported.
Windows built-in tools
Storage Sense (Settings → System → Storage) and Disk Cleanup are included with Windows, cost nothing and cover temporary files, the Recycle Bin and cached update data. They are a good first step. Read each category before you tick it.
BleachBit
BleachBit is an open-source cleaner. Its source code is public and it gives you manual control over what is cleaned, which suits people who prefer open-source software and are comfortable reading what each option does.
Commercial and freemium cleaners
Many cleaners are proprietary and use a free tier with a paid upgrade, or a subscription. Licensing, included extras and what the free version allows differ, so compare the official pages rather than third-party summaries.
Rain Cleaner
Rain Cleaner (Windows 10/11, 64-bit) shows what it found, with an explanation for each item, before it removes anything. The Free version has no ads; Pro has a free 7-day trial (no card). We make it, so weigh this page accordingly: everything above also works with Windows alone.
A safe way to decide
Start with Storage settings to see what is actually using space. Try the built-in tools first, then add a third-party tool only if you want something they do not give you. Keep a backup before any large cleanup.